Joe's Slice of Sicily

Nitin Malla a month ago

This place is pizza perfection. I grew up on NY and I live for food - I've been to 9 of the top 10 pizza places in the world. This is authentic NY style pizza. Yes, it's a little greesy but everything from the pizza to the condiments including garlic powder and parmesian cheese brought back childhood memories. They even have breaded chicken pizza and chicken parm rolls which are almost impossible to find outside of NY/Phili. Joe used to run a pizza place in White Plains which is in the suburbs of NYC. He is passionate about pizza and a good conversationalist. Dare I say, this is the most authentic NY style pizza I've ever had outside of NY! This will be my go to place for my weekly cheat meals.

Bruce Nguyen a month ago

Absolutely gem of a pizza place. It’s located in a gas station, but it’s one of the best pizzas I’ve had. The owner, Joe, was so welcoming and kind. He was born in Sicily!! So the pizza and pasta are legit. They are coming up on one year! The food is absolutely fantastic. The lasagna pizza is to DIE FOR.

Jeanette Michael 4 months ago

I really wanted to love this pizza at first bite, but it didn’t blow me away. The crust (the bottom of the pie, not the edges) was too thick and it could have used more sauce, which i wasn’t expecting from a place with so many reviews about it being just like NY/NJ pizza (I’m from NY). 4/5 because still better than most pizza in Austin! Willing to try again and get a plain cheese pie rather than toppings to get a better taste for it — but I will say, they were generous with the toppings!

Samuel Dixon 2 months ago

This small pizza place has quite a bit of selection and character. I enjoyed pieces of the lasagna and the chicken parm with pesto pizzas, along with a Philly cheese steak pinwheel. It was a bit rained outside and no indoor seeting, although we made the most of it. The staff were very friendly and happy for business. Conveniently, this is a few blocks and maybe a mile walk from Barton Springs.

AdventureDave 2 months ago

Overall - bland. The slice had a crunchy crust as I like it, but lacked flavor as did the sauce. Crust and sauce make the pizza and I failed to recognize anything distinctive about the pizza and why it gets such rave reviews. So, nless I got a slice from a bad pie, I’d suggest going somewhere else. YMMV.