Colony Grill - Tampa Midtown

Kara Leigh Giraffeigh 4 months ago

I now know that Connecticut pizza is a "thing", and that "apizza" thing is delicious...the thin, charred crust is a must! The venue is a warm and wonderful spot in midtown for a feel-good, comforting experience. The casual atmosphere is cozy and the staff is extremely welcoming. Tennille deserves a shout-out for her bright-spirited service and smiles! See you again soon!

Aaron Pierce 2 months ago

I only ordered the cheese pizza well done. I wanted to test this place because I grew up in the south shore of Massachusetts. Nobody makes or has heard of bar pizza in Tampa bay area. This is the best bar pizza you are gonna get without going up north again. They even know what we'll done is! Service was a lil slow but I think its just because I ordered a pizza around 12pm on a Wednesday lol I wish they had a location in Brooksville fl as I am only occasionally in Tampa for work.

Roxanne Anderson 4 months ago

It's not Connecticut pizza. It's more like matzo with a little cheese and even less sauce. They didn't add pounds of sugar to the pizza like most Florida pizzerias, so that was a plus. I was thrilled when I found a Connecticut chain; I texted people before I went. I had to reply back later to say it wasn't Connecticut pizza.

Jessica Z. 8 months ago

The place was oddly dead when I came on a Thursday evening (almost uncomfortably dead lol). I know it's not the original but I came here because Dave Portnoy gave the one in Connecticut a high review. Its a super unique style of pizza, super thin crust with a cheesey top. I found it to be good but not great. Definitely wouldn't disappoint, but wouldn't make you go out of your way for it. 7.2 - that's the review! 🍕 7.2

Sam Woods 4 months ago

Ordered pepperoni, onion and hot oil. The hot oil is a nice touch. Oil infused with serrano peppers. Elizabeth's service was attentive and spot on, but her voice is that of an angel. Truly a mix of Jesus and Fergie. Yes, they only serve pizza; if you are surprised by that you are lazy and walk blindly through life.