Upstate Pizzeria

Holly E. Kaspar, MBA 5 months ago

Best Pizza in the Springs - Maybe all of Colorado! We’ve lived all around Colorado for 15 years and good pizza has alluded us until now. This is legit New York style pizza and is excellent in every way - from the sauce, the crust, and the cheese, to super high quality ingredients. From plain cheese to their incredible mushrooms - to the way they slice the veggie toppings thin so they cook perfectly- everything is amazing! The sausage and pepperoni are also fantastic. We recently tried the Vodka pie which is outrageous- the sauces, buttery herb crust and bits of basil are so good it should be outlawed. We order from here consistently and it’s good every single time. Coming from a family of New Yorkers - they would approve of this place - and the owner is so sweet and kind. Do yourself a favor and check them out - you will not be disappointed.

Monica Whitney 4 months ago

Upstate Pizzeria is the closest thing I’ve found to home in 14 years, and I don’t say that lightly. One bite in and I was instantly transported back to Upstate New York—so much so that I literally had to FaceTime my mother and tell her I finally found real PIZZER again. The quality is unreal: the crust, the sauce, the balance… it’s all done right, no shortcuts, no gimmicks. This is the kind of pizza that reminds you why you fell in love with pizza in the first place. If you grew up with true upstate pizza, this place will hit you straight in the soul. And if you didn’t? Congratulations—you’re about to understand what the hype has always been about. Moose (pizza master) and owner were incredibly welcoming and told us to give “honest” feedback .. this is honest because he was honest… you just don’t get service like this anymore. 10/10 ! We will be back! BBQ chicken pizza was my favorite and I don’t like onions … but by the way, they were rustically grilled with perfection I would order double next time. Buffalo chicken could’ve used a little more spicy sauce, but we arrived later in the lunch experience so I’m assuming that fresh it would’ve been perfect! The prices were perfectly set..and if anything the value is way more than what you pay!! Thanks again!

Lilibeth Meza 4 months ago

Hands down the BEST NY style pizza in Colorado Springs. Every bite tastes like home. I’ve been on a mission to find truly good pizza and wings out here, and this spot absolutely nailed it. We ordered their XXL pizza and buffalo wings for our Super Bowl party and everyone kept asking where it was from. The wings were perfect and the pizza was huge, fresh, and full of flavor. I even made a special request for my pizza loving fiancé and they went above and beyond to make it happen. They’re authentic and originally from Syracuse, NY, and you can definitely taste the difference. This is officially our go to pizza place now. We’ll 100% be back!

Jack Jarrett 2 months ago

The pizza was very tasty, classic NY pie. One 20 inch half cheese half pep and 10 wings fed our family of 8. Rating would be 5 stars if I were only reviewing the pizza. The wings were disappointing. Ordered medium buffalo but there was hardly any buffalo sauce on the wings. They were medium size wings and cooked well just lacking sauce. Service was solid, I walked in right at the pickup time and the food was ready to go (and was not prepared too early because it was still a good temperature when I got it home). Also, this place is tucked away but Google Maps will get you there.

Adam LaGrange 6 months ago

This place is so good! Great staff and great food! Got my slice of pizza, some hot wings, and garlic knots… Soooo good! Definitely coming back for more. *pro tip Hot wings dipped in the garlic knot sauce