Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop

Antoine Shelton 4 months ago

I’ll be honest—I’m usually the person skipping the BBQ sauce entirely. But Nancy’s Pizza has officially changed the game for me. Their house BBQ sauce is absolutely superb; it’s so well-balanced that it won over someone who doesn't even like BBQ sauce. We tried both the BBQ Chicken Pizza and the BBQ Hawaiian Pizza, and both were incredible. The flavors are bold, the crust is exactly what you want from a Chicago staple, and that house sauce really ties everything together. The Highlights: • The Caesar Salad: Do not sleep on this! We added anchovies, and it was excellent—fresh, salty, and the perfect punchy side to the pizza. • The Service: The servers were extremely nice. The customer service was top-tier from start to finish, which really elevated the whole experience. The only slight miss for us were the Buffalo wings, which were a bit mediocre compared to the high bar set by the rest of the meal. However, the pizza and salad more than made up for it. If you’re in Chicago, Nancy’s is a must-visit. Even if you think you don't like BBQ sauce, give theirs a try—you’ll be surprised!

Chris Horntvedt 3 months ago

Nancy’s pizza was recommended to me by two coworkers and I’m so happy we tried it out. The stuffed pizza (deep dish) was delicious and worth the visit on its own. Their tavern style, thin crust pizza was also great. We ordered the cheese stuffed pizza and the Rocco’s Party (Italian sausage, mushroom, green pepper). The sausage was flavorful and the crust was crispy. I’d advise on making a reservation as it can get busy on nights and weekends. They also offer a take out option for anyone not wanting to dine in.

Jason Johnson 3 months ago

Amazing service. Drove about 3 hours out of my way to try their stuffed pizzas after seeing them online and was blown away. Our server let us know what we were getting into so we knew what to order. We ordered a large stuffed pizza with pepperoni and some mozzarella sticks. The mozzarella sticks were served.with some sort of pesto-based sauce along with the.marinara, making it a refreshing take on an appetizer I have had multiple times before. The stuffed pizza was amazing. The sauce is great and there's plenty of it. Definitely worth the drive to get here. We will be ordering some of the frozen pizzas in the future.

Jason Powell 3 months ago

Man what a good pie. This place is so official. I got it for delivery and it was amazing. The sausage is so flavorful. They layered my pepperoni underneath the sausage and phenomenal. They’re making each one of their pizzas with love. The pizza itself is cut into smaller pizzas which makes it a great way to eat. Man I can’t say enough good things about this pizza. Only thing I wish the center of the crust was a lil more crisp, besides that these folks delivered me a perfect pie. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.

Dwight 2 months ago

Great experience on the west side, enjoyed the fact that you could have more than one sauce on the chicken wings.Deep dish was perfect toppings, not very expensive to add. Good wine list for pizza. Made a reservation which you can and I suggest. Could tell the ingredients were fresh. Service was knowledgeable.