Eleventh Street Pizza – Downtown Miami

Sergio Licea 4 months ago

Wow, the pizza is so delicious and the staff is so friendly. I’m on a journey to find the top 10 New York style pizzas in Miami and this one ranks #1 so far!

Kristan Bodden 4 months ago

Have been here 3xs over past year. 1st time was epic bc the pepperoni sicilian was just unreal so i ordered one of everything and most other stuff esp garlic knots was just overpriced meh. The 2nd time was abysmal with tons of thick nasty cheese and undercooked dough. The guy apologized after i said it was totally disgusting and said they had a new pizza guy. Offered to remake but i just wanted to puke so i left. Both times were the most expensive pizza experiences i'd had. Really very expensive for pizza even for miami where everything is priced at anomalously high price points. 3rd time? 1245pm today 6mos after my last terrible experience. Door locked but people eating inside. Girl comes to open door and says that they're closed bc she was there alone. She was very nice but this was the time I'd try to let them make up for the last time i was there. My take is as follows: 1) erratic food quality 2) the price point gives them no margin for error yet 2/3 of the time, they foul something up Try it if you like but the value proposition is way off bc off the outrageous price point and the swings in quality

Steven Diaz 3 months ago

I visited your location tonight at 8:33 PM and was disappointed to find you were already out of cheesesteaks and cookies, despite being open until 2:00 AM. However, I want to commend Frank and Eric for their excellent customer service; they were very helpful and provided a delicious pizza instead. Please consider increasing your stock of these items to better serve evening customers cookies and cheesesteaks

Monet Howard a week ago

Unfortunately, our visit was disappointing from the moment we arrived. We were informed that the restaurant was already out of the garlic confit, which was frustrating, but what made the situation worse was the attitude we received from the staff. Rather than feeling welcomed or offered an alternative, we were met with an unfriendly and dismissive demeanor that immediately changed the tone of our visit. As paying customers, we understand that restaurants can run out of menu items, especially during busy hours. However, there is no excuse for poor customer service. Hospitality is about how guests are treated, especially when things don't go as planned. The interaction left us feeling unwelcome, undervalued, and honestly disappointed. Because of the experience, we chose to leave and went elsewhere for dinner. We ended up at Pucci's, where we were treated warmly and enjoyed our meal. The contrast in service was impossible to ignore. I was genuinely excited to visit Eleventh Street Pizza, but the negative attitude and lack of hospitality completely ruined the experience. No customer should be made to feel like an inconvenience. Based on this interaction, I have no desire to return, and I hope management takes customer service more seriously moving forward. A great pizza can bring people in the door, but great hospitality is what keeps them coming back.

Vicki G. 7 months ago

And with my niece before a Heat game. What a fantastic little find in Dwntwn Miami!! Pizza by the slice, beer on tap, and great rock-n-roll tunes. They have pepperoni with hot honey that is absolutely delicious. Felt like I was at a neighborhood pizza joint in Jersey. A must try!!