Five Star Pizza

Don Smith 2 months ago

Im actually pretty pissed off right now. I've lived near this place for 2 years now and just tried them for the 1st time tonight. I ordered the special which is a large 1 topping pizza and garlic knots for $17.99. The reason im pissed is because I could have been eating here this whole time!! Both the pizza and garlic knots were delicious! The sauce is amazing, the crust is nice and chewy and crisp on the edges. This is by far the best pizza I've had in Jacksonville. Give em a try you won't be disappointed

John 13:7 6 months ago

I devoured their pineapple pizza. I love their big slices. Two took care of me but the third topped me off for dinner. I was upset that I didn't leave room for the wings. The hot wings showed my nose no mercy, it was just letting me know that they were unenjoyed deliciousness. I'm just so happy I have food for like 2 more meals. Their style of cheese makes the pie. It's not greasy and all fulfilling. Will be ordering from here again.

Tiffany Dempsey 2 months ago

I used to love Five Star. Moved to Washington. Came back for a visit and was extremely disappointed. Pizza was not even cut and cinnamon rolls were hard. They actually made noise when knocking on them. Was told pizza would be ready in 3 minutes when we showed up for pickup. Took another 15 minutes. While at the window the staff actually picked up and hung up the phone several times.

Amy Burke 4 weeks ago

Been going to Five Star Pizza for well over 14 yrs. I hadn't ordered, for no particular reason, for a long time and just did. Thanks for reminding me why they are so good. I ordered the Veggie pizza with bacon and their Teriyaki Boneless wings. What flavor and balance!

Lauren Hoyer 2 months ago

Idk what’s going on here but it’s been my go to for years I never had issues. I order at least 1-2x a month, ask for extra sauce on my pizza every time and never fails it’s actually dry the first couple bites until you get to the crust, then it has a little extra bit of sauce… Not exaggerating. Do the cooks know how to properly sauce a pizza? At that, evenly ? I always have an issue with quality and consistency and I’ve been reluctant to complain bc I’ve been so loyal for years and give chance after chance hoping for a change but here we are.