Rosati's Pizza - Milwaukee Bay View

Heather Hinzpeter 5 months ago

I ordered for my son's birthday. It was my first time having it. Undoubtedly the best pizza I've ever had in my life. The stuffed pizza is definitely the one to get. So big and piled with toppings, I could only eat one piece. It's a value when you think of it that way. And when I signed up for their loyalty rewards, I automatically got 20% off my entire order.

Trisha Crivello a month ago

Pizza here is phenomenal! Pasta was terrible very disappointing really had high expectations considering the pizza has always been a 10/10 Meatballs tasted like they were processed and came from a can. Mozzarella sticks were great as well as the marinara sauce. Will definitely order the pizza but will never order the pasta again!

Bob Wooten a month ago

I've driven past Rosati's more times than I can remember. I always assumed it was just another strip mall pizza place. On Saturday I was looking for a chicago style pizza on Milwaukee's south shore, there were few options, I skipped Rosati's because at first glance I didn't see deep dish. I had no luck, so I came back to Rosati's, I was disappointed it would take to long to deliver and abandoned the idea, Sunday night my husband suggested giving it a try since it was only 4pm. Well, I'm glad I did order, the crust was crispy and delicious, the sauce paired very well with the toppings, fillings and crust. Darn good pizza, lm glad we did give Rosati's a shot. I'll definitely be ordering again. 10" chicago style with ricotta, mozzarella and pepperoni. Jalapeno poppers.

Jacob Perez 4 months ago

By far, one of the best places to eat Chicago style deep dish pizza and calzóns. Been coming here for years. You don't need to make a special trip to Illinois, you can get it right here in Milwaukee. I found that ordering their food online is faster and more efficient

J Wrizzle 3 years ago

I really enjoyed my first Rosati’s Pizza experience. I called in for pick up & was placed on a short hold before I placed my order. I definitely recommend their Chicago style deep dish pizza. I had the smaller 10 inch which had about six nice sized slices. I also suggest the pick four option where you get your choice of four toppings. My four toppings were pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, and extra cheese. It was as close to perfect as you can get outside of Chicago! Very delicious. Make your next move your best move & get you some thick, cheesey, delicious Rosati’s!!!!