American Gothic Pizza and Gelato

Nicholas Molt 9 months ago

This place was fantastic. The pizza the appetizers the sangria the sandwich, and the gelato were all awesome! (I had the new pumpkin pie gelato... so good...) The owner was very nice. All the employees that I met were super friendly. If you’re reading this go try it out for yourself.

Taylor 2 months ago

We have been coming here since they opened last year, and it’s our #1 pizza spot in OKC. Our family is well versed in italian pizza/food and this is top notch. Better yet, it’s family owned and local. The owners are always there running it, and even make their gelato from scratch. We have so enjoyed getting to know more about the place and the love they put into it. We are probably here once every 2 weeks at least and have never been disappointed with the food. Also best espresso martini and sangria!

Thomas Dafinger 6 months ago

Delicious pizza! I ordered via a food delivery app a Margherita, a Marinara and The Veggie white pizza. All of them were prepared the neapolitan style and very tasty. The ingredients were fresh and the crust had a good consistency. I just missed more of the cheese on the Margherita pizza. The process from ordering to delivery was almost even faster than indicated in the app.

Blaine Atchley 4 months ago

Solid pizza with a neat atmosphere and great service. I got the featured pizza of the day, the Chicken Parm. The crust was especially great. Don’t miss out on the gelato either!

Michelle Read 7 months ago

I had a fantastic experience at this pizza restaurant! The crust was perfectly cooked—crispy on the outside and soft inside, just the way it should be. The sauce was full of flavor, adding the perfect balance to every bite. The restaurant itself was spotless, and the staff were fast and friendly, making the whole visit even better. I also tried the chocolate chip cookie, and it was absolutely delicious—warm, gooey, and the perfect sweet ending to the meal. Highly recommend this place for anyone looking for great pizza and excellent service!