Yellow Brick Pizza

Emma McLaughlin 5 months ago

On January 27th I hit up @yellowbrickpizza for their snazzy Restaurant Week deal — and trust me, you do not want to miss this one!!!!! For just $25, I got: 🥗 vegan antipasto salad 🍕 a 10-inch vegan Fresh Prince pizza 🍰 and a to-die-for slice of New York–style vegan cheesecake They have so many great vegan and regular food options to satisfy everyone’s preferences. I’m able to take friends and family here for a nice night out around Columbus. I couldn’t recommend Yellow Brick Pizza more! 🤍

JustCayti 3 months ago

The build your own deep dish pizza was so good! You can pick whichever toppings you want and the price was fairly reasonable. I also got the twice cooked wings I love the carmelized flavor of the bbq when it’s not dripping. I didn’t love the seating options but the vibes and atmosphere are super cute and retro and if you come at a slow time plenty of room.

Rasheedah Crawley 3 months ago

We love Yellow Brick Pizza, stopped in tonight and grab their wings. They are big, well seasoned and sauced and cooked perfectly. Service was great! They also have arcade machines that can be played while waiting.

Willow 4 months ago

Very disappointed in the food, service, wait time, value, cleanliness and overall experience. Went on a Saturday late afternoon (family of 3) and noted only one other table w/ customers so thought we would get quick service. There is a lot of seating, high ceilings and a lot of natural light from the windows (about the only good things we can comment on). Right away, noticed missing buttons and holes in the fabric on the back of the booth we were sitting in. The seats were old w/ large cracks. Server came pretty quickly to take our order but seemed unfamiliar with the menu when we had questions. Noted prices were pretty high compared to other pizza places. Ours were about $20 for a 10" pizza. Between the three of us, got two different pizzas and a meatball sub, plus a deep dish pizza and calzone to take home for later. Took almost an hour to get our food w/ no updates, apologies, or explanation from our server. Made no sense given we were one of two total tables in the whole place. We had to go to the bar the first time to get our drink refills b/c the server (who was also tending the bar w/ no customers at it) never returned. When we finally got our food, it was delivered by another person who informed us they would now be our server. Informed us our server left for the day. Very frustrated the original server never informed us he was leaving. The food was so disappointing. Both pizzas had very little toppings and the toppings stopped about 2 inches from the edge of the crust. Both pizzas had large bubbles in them. The crust was dry, hard, and flavorless. I normally love crust but didn’t eat it b/c it was so bad which left a lot of uneaten food in the box b/c there was so much crust on eat piece. The bottom of the pizzas were slightly burned w/ little black specks getting all over our plates and fingers. My pizza was supposed to have balsamic glaze on it. It was barely visible and I couldn't taste it. I requested a side of glaze, which they forgot, so had to ask again. The meatball sub was less than average with a lot of dry hoagie type roll and very little sauce. Went to restroom and noted large areas of black type mold on the ceiling tiles from some sort of leak. If the leak was fixed, changing the tiles out would be easy as it was a drop ceiling. Unsure why you would want customers to see and/ or breathe that! When we opened our deep dish pizza at home, noted the entire bottom was black/ burned. We had high hopes based on some of the reviews we read and the space has potential. However, the entire experience was not good, felt like we wasted our money. Def. would not return or recommend.

Jim Weaver 4 months ago

02/07/2026 Love the Tristano's style pizza here! So delicious! Side salad and garlic knots were also a delight! Can't wait to come back! First time at the Rich St location, great place! We had the Chicago Style and in was amazing! Our server was also great! We really enjoyed Yellow Brick and will be back!