Mikey's Late Night Slice

David Bleke 5 months ago

Cool vibes for a late night pizza joint. It's 2 separate places in one. Bar and drinks are 1 and pizza is the other so have to order separately. Pizza was a good NY Style Pizza with some added spices. Bees was cold. Nice staff. Restaurant seating with a small bar top seating.

Mage837 3 months ago

Since I've moved to Columbus from New York, I've been looking for a good pizza spot. Mikey's not only scratches my itch for good pizza but the staff makes sure you're having a great time. I would like to thank Rae and the rest of the staff for such a good experience.

Nicole Green 5 months ago

We were in the area for a Blue Jackets game, I had only had Mikeys at concerts in Columbus and didnt realize they had a store front so close to Nationwide. This will 100% be our stop before every game now! We got the vegan BBQ chicken pizza and the cheesy garlic bread (neither of us are vegan, it just looked really good). The pizza was incredible and I wouldn't have even known it was vegan if they didnt tell us. Love that they have a dipping sauce station and you can buy the sauces to go. Crust was perfect and service was friendly and efficient. Cant wait to go back!

Jared - Brown Water Banter 3 months ago

The pizza was excellent—thin, crispy crust with a really flavorful sauce. I had the Meathead while I was in town for the Arnold Classic and it did not disappoint. The staff had my order ready right when I walked in the door, and everyone was very friendly. Great experience overall.

Jeremy Allen 10 months ago

Arguably the best slice of NYC style pizza I’ve had both in and out of the city. Pizza Rat might end up moving to Columbus… Really fresh complex flavors and I appreciate the “or not” variations. Hot Take, NYC could use one more slice shop…