Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North

Deashun 4 months ago

This was a very good Italian restaurant and bar in the back. I like that you can walk in and see all of the history of the place throughout the walls and decor. My wife liked that they had gold peak tea on tap. Their hot sauce was really good on the pizza also. They thanked us for coming and it was a nice experience to eat at a new place on Columbus Ohio. They are located near shops and even a chocolate store right across the street. Goodfellas Pizza was delicious 🤤. Me and my wife enjoyed ourselves. And next time we are in town and want pizza we will stop in again.

Amanda Herrera 4 months ago

Pizza was delicious. If you like cheeses, recommend you to get extra. The cheese portion on Paulie's was minimal and a few open pieces spots. Toppings were hearty and delicious. One of the pizza orders was not the size they would have liked, so they made a new one at no charge. Wait was very long. Small area to eat.

Stacie H a month ago

One of our new favorite places in the Short North! Pizza is great! The cocktails are so good and they have an incredible Bourbon selection. We always have great service even when it’s packed! We go here at least once a month since it opened.

Morganne Johnson 4 months ago

Fun atmosphere and huge pizza slices. I asked to add pepperoni but the girl just grabbed the slice and placed it in the oven then went to check out when I wasn't done ordering. Sign says $4.50 per slice then was charged extra for the slices having 4 toppings (guess they consider cheese a topping since as mine only had 3. She didnt bother asking if we wanted anything to drink. $26 for 4 pizza slices a 22 inch wouldve been cheaper. Everyone else was friendly and willing to help

Sevastian Javier 7 months ago

First time here. I got the regular cheese pizza and it's ok but It could be a lot better honestly. I've had better cheese pizza; however, im giving this place 4 stars in the meantime because I will try out the other pizzas and hopefully it will earn 5 stars.