Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave

Alexandrea Rivera 2 months ago

We were in Indiana for spring break from New York and after a long day sight seeing we found Good Fellas Pizzeria. We loved the theme and thought that was so cool! We ordered the biggest cheese pizza they had and 3 drinks and paid $50. Or was totally worth it! We fed 8 of us. The pizza slices were bigger than my head! It took about 15 minutes for us to get the pizza. It was a comfortable spot and very clean. We will definitely be back! I plan to do a vlog on my tik tok channel next time we come. Thanks, Good Fellas!!

Ken Peach 3 weeks ago

Food was good! Pizza was large, and you need to ask them to cook it well done. Then it comes out the way a pizza should be cooked! The team cooking was pretty amazing! Will go back.

Steven Peguero 3 weeks ago

The pizza is hit or miss. If you see college age kids in the front just go to the bar. I love the pizza when it gets made right, toasted, and given the choice to pick your slice before served. Warren and Rae are the best bartenders seriously. Home of the famous Mabuhay. You wont regret you're visit at their saloon in the rear. Not speaking for any other bartenders just fyi.

kakabay esenov a month ago

I was traveling to Indianapolis and stopped by Goodfellas Pizzeria. The pizza crust was amazing, and the whole pizza was absolutely delicious. I can honestly say it was the best pizza I’ve tried so far. The flavors were perfectly balanced, and every bite tasted fresh. I’ll definitely stop by again whenever I’m in the area.

Jamie Mattingly 4 months ago

Dine in. I had the lunch special slice of pizza, extra long breadstick and a drink.$10. Really filling and I have a snack for tonight ( or my dogs devour it). Really convenient location and very friendly staff. Did I mention first time here? I did I think.. I’ll be back!!