Vinny's N.Y. Pizza & Grill - Midtown

Laura 3 months ago

This is a nice place to get a classic NY slice of pizza. The slices are large. I got plain cheese and really enjoyed them. I got the special which is 2 slices and a drink for $10, which I probably could've done with just one slice given how large they are. Friendly people, my order came out quick, and a few other patrons enjoying dine-in orders. I will be back. I also like they have a 100 rating from the health dept. They have a nice patio and a good neighborhood feel.

Ctgb 3 weeks ago

I recently visited Vinny's N.Y. Pizza & Grill in Midtown Atlanta, and it was a great spot for anyone craving classic New York-style pizza. The restaurant had a casual and welcoming atmosphere that made it easy to relax and enjoy a meal, whether dining alone or with friends. The pizza was definitely the highlight of my visit. The crust had the perfect balance of crispness and chewiness, and the toppings tasted fresh and flavorful. Each slice was generously sized, just like the kind of pizza you would expect from a traditional New York pizzeria. Beyond the pizza, the menu offered plenty of options, making it a good choice for groups with different tastes. The staff was friendly and efficient, providing quick service without making the experience feel rushed. Even during a busy period, the team remained attentive and helpful, which added to the overall positive impression. For first-time visitors, I recommend ordering pizza by the slice if you want to sample different varieties before committing to a whole pie. Visiting during lunch can be a convenient option for a quick meal, while dinner offers a great opportunity to enjoy the full menu. If you're dining with friends, sharing a large pizza is an excellent value. Overall, Vinny's N.Y. Pizza & Grill delivers delicious pizza, generous portions, and dependable service. I would definitely return the next time I'm in Midtown Atlanta.

Power 3 Multimedia 3 months ago

I’ve given Vinny’s Pizza in Midtown Atlanta multiple chances, but unfortunately my experiences have been consistently disappointing. Over the past two months, I’ve ordered pizza and salad three separate times. On two of those occasions, the food arrived in poor condition—toppings shifted, presentation off, and not something I felt comfortable eating. Today was the final attempt. When my delivery arrived, the safety seal on the box was already open, which immediately raised concerns. I drove to the location to address it directly with the manager. After showing him the issue, he stated there was “nothing wrong with the pizza.” I asked him a simple question: Would you eat a pizza that was delivered with a broken seal? His response was that he only picks up his food and doesn’t use delivery. When I requested a remake, he refused and said it was the responsibility of the delivery service. At that point, it was clear there was no accountability or willingness to resolve the issue. In total, I’ve spent over $120 here on food I ultimately refused to eat. I understand that delivery issues can happen, but customer service and food safety should always come first. Unfortunately, this experience fell short on both. I won’t be returning.

Jamel Robinson a month ago

10 out of 10 I highly recommend. The pizza is a 10. Service is a 10. Ambiance is a 10. Team is a 10. This was my first time here and it was absolutely amazing!!! Oh and don’t mind the blanket space on the plate I already ate my first slice.

BTB 4 months ago

Great NY style pizza in Midtown ATL. Love coming here. Very nice people and they are always consistent with quality of food.