Fellini's Pizza

Eddie Peltier a month ago

I live near this location and visit frequently. Tonight I visited and placed my usual Togo order 3 Sicilian slices pepperoni and banana peppers. Normally the pizza is AMAZING, tonight not so much 😫. Not only was my pizza missing the pepperoni but it was severally undercooked as you can see in the photo, these Sicilian slices look like normal slices. Unfortunately my head was else where and this didn’t fully register till I got home.

Ray Dude 6 months ago

I've eaten that Fellini's pizza for many years every time it's quite consistent and seems to be fresh. Obviously they make their own dough and sauce that is quite evident. This location did not disappoint. I met with my oldest daughter who lives in Grant Park and we talked for hours. I had two peroni draft beers, which were great addition to their pizza. Overall, I highly recommend this pizza company to anybody who wants authentic fresh pizza and not a chain.

Chante Gilliam 3 months ago

We moved here 5 years ago from NY and it wasn’t easy finding good pizza. I like toppings on my pizza sometimes but as a native New Yorker and avid pizza lover, I judge based on the quality of a good cheese slice and Fellini’s hits the spot every time! The dough is just the way I like it and the sauce and cheese is just right!

Que The Traveler 11 months ago

It definitely has an old retro look to it, but the food was pretty damn good. I had a slice of pepperoni and a slice of supreme, both served hot with just the right amount of crisp on the crust. The sauce had that classic, slightly sweet taste that reminded me of old-school pizzerias, and the cheese was perfectly melted—not too greasy, just flavorful and fresh. The staff was laid-back but attentive, and the overall vibe was relaxed, like a neighborhood spot that doesn’t try too hard because it doesn’t have to. It’s not fancy, but that’s part of its charm. If you’re looking for a casual place to grab solid pizza without all the extra fluff, Fellini’s on Ponce is definitely worth stopping by.

Greg Barron a month ago

1st timer. Pizza was on point. Night on Ponce(beer) was cold & always with a bold flavor. Guy taking my order was real cool. Nice outside patio.