Emmy Squared Pizza: West Midtown

Ctgb 3 weeks ago

I stopped by Emmy Squared Pizza in West Midtown expecting a good pizza, but I left wondering why I hadn't discovered this place sooner. From the outside, it feels like a casual neighborhood spot, but once you're inside, the atmosphere is lively, modern, and surprisingly inviting. The star of the show is, of course, the pizza. The thick, crispy crust had the perfect balance of crunch and softness, creating a texture that's completely different from traditional New York-style pizza. Every bite was packed with flavor, and it was obvious that high-quality ingredients played a big role in the final result. Even after a few slices, I found myself reaching for another piece. What I appreciated most was how relaxed the entire experience felt. The staff was friendly, efficient, and happy to answer questions about the menu. Whether you're a first-time visitor or a regular, they make you feel right at home. A helpful tip: come hungry. The portions are more filling than they appear, and sharing a couple of menu items with friends is a great way to try more of what the restaurant offers. If you're visiting on a weekend evening, making a reservation can save you some waiting time. Overall, Emmy Squared Pizza delivers excellent food, welcoming service, and a fun atmosphere that keeps people coming back. It's easily one of the most enjoyable pizza spots I've visited in Atlanta.

Courtney Harris a year ago

Arrived with a small group on a Saturday at 11:30a for lunch. We were immediately seated. The service was great from beginning to end. It was so nice to have the big open window for fresh air and the view outside. The burger and pizzas were delicious! The waffle fries were also cooked perfectly. Highly recommend!

Kien Hunter 3 weeks ago

I love Emmy squared. Since I'm from the Midwest, Detroit-style pizza is a really big deal to me. They have pretty good pizza. You can get a myriad of different flavors and toppings to go along with it. They have some good specials but if you want the classics, they have that. Their other food is actually pretty good too though but I stick with the pizza personally . If you come around this venue, just know that you're going to have to worry about parking because their parking lot is really small. They do have a parking lot across the street that you can pay for. The first hour is free over there next door to the food terminal. Of course down the street there's street parking as well if you can get it but the lot itself that they have is very small and it doesn't hold more than 10 cars . The pizza you get comes at a minimum of six pieces but they're not overly large so it's just the right amount if you want to do it by yourself or share it .

April H. 4 weeks ago

Wonderful experience. We came because of the amazing Le Big Matt burger featured on Burgers with Buck on Fox 5. Man....let me tell you...that burger is magical!!!! The pizza was also very tasty and you must save room for dessert (hopefully you love chocolate). The drinks are nice, strong 💪🏾 😋, and mixed well. Hopefully you get Jason as your bartender and server...very polite and attentive. Thank you.

Zipporah Ford 5 months ago

I just went to Emmy Squared Pizza in New York in December. I just so happen to be driving past it on the way home and realize that it’s not far from my house so the next day I had to come here and try the pizza to see if it was the same and absolutely delicious. I built my own pizza sausage banana, peppers, mushrooms, pepper. It was just as good as the one in New York so whenever I’m feeling like a square slide to Emmy’s will definitely be seeing me :)