Andy's Pizza Adams Morgan

Afterhours Fabrication 6 months ago

I brought the family here for lunch based on the good reviews and it was between point A and B during a vacation visit. Andy's did not disappoint! The pizza was excellent, different for sure but a good chewy crust with crunchy snall bubbles. And they use the small pepperonis that cup when cooked.. 👌

Sreekanth Ganesh 2 months ago

I never will ever get tired of Andy's. The crust is beautiful and crunchy and soft on the inside. Every pizza slice is a beauty and tastes wonderful.

John Brown18E 3 months ago

Nestled among the edgy bars and eateries of Adams Morgan, Andy’s Pizza stands in a league of its own. As someone who spent a decade in New York—my "baptism under capitalist fire" —I can safely say their NY-style slice is perfection. We recently had a bit of a mishap with an incomplete Apple Pay transaction during a heavy dinner rush, but the young lead on staff handled it with incredible grace. After we realized the error and reordered, he even treated me to a complimentary beverage—a golden elixir so smooth it felt like a gift from above. While waiting, I grabbed a pepperoni and sausage slice that was honestly life-changing; it felt like hitting a walk-off home run or that perfect first kiss. I probably need to get out more, but I have so much love for this staff. They were patient and kind to this "late-stage boomer," and it’s rare to find that level of service and quality combined.

Clint K 5 months ago

Got the margarita slice. It was a decent slice, but nothing special. For $5, I wish the slice was bigger. The sauce was sweeter than most places I’ve tried. Probably wouldn’t go out of my way to come back. However, the staff was pleasant and store was clean.

Julia Omotade 8 months ago

The pizza that I received was completely - and I mean completely - inedible. It was absolutely BURNT to a crisp. I’ve had Andy’s three times. The first time was fine. The second time I walked a half an hour to get pizza, only to find that the bottoms of the pizzas were completely black and burnt to a crisp. I tried to take a bite, but it tasted and looked like charcoal. I legit couldn’t salvage even one bite. I had to go through the trouble of calling the manager, and he was able to give me a refund. A giant waste of time. Since this only happened to me once, I placed a Andy’s order again tonight. I was so wary of my past experience, that I called the front desk person **before** placing my Uber eats order. I told her that the last time I got pizza that was burnt to a crisp, and she very kindly asked for my name and assured me that this would not be the case this time. Got my pizza. Completely burnt to a crisp. Again. I tried to take a bite out of denial, and the charcoal taste hurt my stomach. Just wasted $40 on a pizza that I can’t even take a bite of. Clearly not just a one time mistake.